top of page

Made in Utica: Four Hometown Favorites Worth Coming Back For

8 hours ago
2 min read


From a half moon cookie to a plate of chicken riggies, Utica’s signature foods tell the story of a city that knows how to make people feel at home.

UTICA, N.Y. — Order greens in Utica and you might get hot peppers, prosciutto and a golden layer of breadcrumbs. Ask for a slice of tomato pie and it’ll likely come at room temperature. And if someone offers you a half moon, the only question is which side you’re biting into first.

That’s the fun of eating in Utica. Even familiar foods come with a local twist, and the person sitting next to you probably has a favorite place to get each one.

Half Moon Cookies

Utica’s half moon cookie traces its roots to Hemstrought’s Bakery in the 1920s. The soft, cake-like cookie gets a generous coat of vanilla frosting on one side and chocolate fudge frosting on the other. You can pick a favorite, of course, but the best bite might be right down the middle.

Chicken Riggies

Chicken riggies took shape in Utica-area Italian restaurants and became one of the region’s signature dishes. Rigatoni catches the creamy tomato sauce, chicken makes it a meal, and hot cherry peppers give it a kick. Every kitchen seems to have its own idea of how much heat belongs in the sauce, which gives you a perfectly good reason to try another plate.

Utica Greens

Escarole gets the full Utica treatment with hot peppers, prosciutto, breadcrumbs and grated cheese. The result is savory, a little spicy and crisp on top. Order a plate for the table and see how long it takes before someone reaches for the last forkful.

Utica-Style Tomato Pie

Local Italian bakeries made this one their own. A thick, airy crust carries a rich, slightly sweet tomato sauce and a light dusting of Romano. Traditionally served at room temperature, it’s the kind of food you can bring to a family gathering and watch disappear while everyone’s still saying hello.

There’s something inspiring about how ordinary these ingredients are. Flour, tomatoes, greens and peppers became dishes people miss when they move away and look forward to when they come home. Generations of Utica bakers, restaurant cooks and families kept making them, sharing them and adding their own touches. Pull up a chair in Utica today, and you can still taste what they built.

bottom of page